top of page

Is Herbal Tea Really Tea? The Difference Between Herbal Tea and True Tea

2 hours ago
5 min read

Ask for a cup of tea in Britain and you'll most likely be handed black tea with a splash of milk. Ask for chamomile and you'll still call it tea. But is herbal tea actually tea? Strictly speaking, no, and the reason is surprisingly simple.

Steaming herbal tea in a glass cup on a plate with rosemary, ginger slices, and dried herbs in a bright, soft white setting.
Rosemary and peppermint infusion

The Short Answer

No, strictly speaking herbal tea isn't real tea. True tea (black, green, white and oolong) is always made from the leaves of one plant: the tea plant, Camellia sinensis. Herbal tea is an infusion of other plants, such as herbs, flowers, fruit, roots, seeds or spices. Think chamomile, peppermint, ginger or rooibos. That's why herbal tea is also called a tisane or an infusion.

In everyday English, "herbal tea" is simply the name we use, and that's perfectly fine. Some countries are stricter: in the Netherlands, for example, the word for tea officially refers only to products made from the tea plant.


Herbal Tea vs True Tea at a Glance


True tea

Herbal tea

Plant

Camellia sinensis, the tea plant

Herbs, flowers, fruit, roots, seeds or spices

Examples

Black, green, white, oolong, pu-erh, matcha

Chamomile, peppermint, rooibos, ginger, hibiscus

Caffeine

Naturally contains caffeine

Usually caffeine-free (yerba maté is an exception)

Water

70–100°C, depending on the type

Freshly boiled water

Steeping time

1–5 minutes

5–10 minutes, ideally covered

Flavour

From fresh and grassy to malty and smoky

As varied as the plants themselves


What Is True Tea?

All true tea comes from Camellia sinensis, an evergreen shrub grown in places such as China, India, Sri Lanka, Japan and Kenya. Black, green, white and oolong tea are not different plants: the difference lies in how the leaves are processed, and above all in how much they are allowed to oxidise after picking.

  • Green tea: heated soon after picking so it barely oxidises. Fresh, grassy and light. Matcha is finely ground green tea.

  • White tea: young buds and leaves, dried gently. Delicate and subtle.

  • Oolong: partly oxidised, sitting somewhere between green and black tea.

  • Black tea: fully oxidised, giving the strong, malty flavour of a classic British cuppa.

  • Pu-erh: tea that is aged or fermented, with a deep, earthy taste.


What Is Herbal Tea?

Herbal tea is any drink made by steeping plants other than the tea plant in hot water. Almost every part of a plant can be used:

  • Leaves: peppermint, lemon balm, sage, rosemary, thyme

  • Flowers: chamomile, lavender, hibiscus, elderflower

  • Roots: ginger, turmeric, liquorice root

  • Seeds and spices: fennel, cinnamon, cloves, star anise

  • Fruit and peel: rosehip, apple, citrus peel

Soft leaves and flowers release their flavour quickly in hot water. Tougher roots, bark and seeds give more when you simmer them for a while, which is exactly how our drinkable simmer pots work.


New to herbal tea? Our guide What Is Herbal Tea? Everything You Need to Know covers the herbs to use, steeping times and blends.


Tisane, infusion or herbal tea?

These words mostly mean the same thing. "Tisane" is the French term for a herbal drink, and an "infusion" is anything steeped in hot water. When you simmer roots or spices rather than steeping them, the result is strictly called a decoction. In everyday life, "herbal tea" covers all of them.


The In-Between Cases

A few popular drinks blur the line, so here's where they belong:

  • Rooibos: made from the South African red bush (Aspalathus linearis). It's often called red tea, but it is a herbal tea and naturally caffeine-free. Green rooibos is simply rooibos that hasn't been oxidised, not green tea.

  • Honeybush: a close relative of rooibos, also caffeine-free, with a slightly honeyed taste.

  • Yerba maté: made from a South American holly (Ilex paraguariensis). It's a herbal tea, but one of the few that naturally contains caffeine.

  • Chai: traditional masala chai is black tea simmered with spices and milk, so it's real tea. Caffeine-free versions swap the black tea for rooibos.

  • Earl Grey: black tea flavoured with bergamot, so real tea too.

  • Fruit tea: blends of hibiscus, apple and dried fruit are usually herbal, but some contain black or green tea as well. Check the ingredients.


How to Tell from the Label

  • If the ingredients include Camellia sinensis, black tea, green tea, white tea or matcha, the drink is real tea and contains caffeine.

  • Words like herbal infusion, tisane or caffeine-free usually point to a herbal tea.

  • Blends such as "green tea with mint" or "spiced black tea" combine both, so they contain caffeine.

  • If you avoid caffeine in the evening, read the full ingredient list rather than relying on the name or the colour of the box.


Brewing Tips for Both

True tea

  • Green tea: 70–80°C for 2–3 minutes. Boiling water makes it bitter.

  • White tea: 75–85°C for 2–4 minutes.

  • Oolong: 85–95°C for 3–5 minutes.

  • Black tea: just off the boil for 3–5 minutes.


Herbal tea

  • Leaves and flowers: pour over freshly boiled water and steep for 5–10 minutes. Cover the cup so the aromatic oils stay in your tea.

  • Amounts: about 1–2 teaspoons of dried herbs or a small handful of fresh herbs per mug.

  • Roots and spices: simmer ginger, cinnamon or cloves gently for 10–20 minutes for a fuller flavour.

  • Loose herbs: a muslin bag makes them easy to lift out. Read more in What Is a Herb Sachet?


A small note: herbal teas are lovely everyday drinks, not medicines, and not every herb suits everyone. If you're pregnant, breastfeeding or take regular medication, check with your doctor or pharmacist before drinking a particular herb often.


Ready to brew? Start with our rosemary tea, thyme tea or clove tea recipes.


Final Thoughts

So herbal tea isn't tea in the botanical sense, but that takes nothing away from it. True tea gives you one remarkable plant in endless styles, while herbal tea opens the door to the whole garden and spice cupboard. Whichever you reach for, the ritual of brewing a warm cup is the same.


You might also like


Herbal Tea vs Tea: FAQ

1. Is herbal tea real tea?

Not strictly. Real tea is made from the leaves of the tea plant, Camellia sinensis. Herbal tea is an infusion of other plants, such as herbs, flowers, fruit, roots or spices, which is why it's also called a tisane.

2. Does herbal tea contain caffeine?

Most herbal teas are naturally caffeine-free. The main exceptions are yerba maté and guayusa, and blends that include black or green tea leaves.

3. Is rooibos a herbal tea?

Yes. Rooibos comes from the South African red bush, not the tea plant, so it's a herbal tea and naturally caffeine-free, even though it's often called red tea.

4. Is chai a herbal tea?

Usually not. Traditional masala chai is black tea simmered with spices and milk, so it contains caffeine. Some caffeine-free chai blends use rooibos instead.

5. Why is herbal tea called tea if it isn't tea?

Because it's brewed the same way: by steeping plant material in hot water. Over time the word tea came to describe the drink and the ritual as much as the plant.

6. Can you mix herbs with real tea?

Absolutely. Mint with green tea, bergamot in Earl Grey and spices in chai are all classic combinations. Just remember that any blend with tea leaves contains caffeine.

Comments


bottom of page